Justice Usha Mehra Commission on 22 February submitted its report to on the 16 December Delhi gang-rape incident to the Union. held on were noted and approved by the Commission. Agenda Item No Recommendations of Justice Usha Mehra. Committee Report regarding. headed by Justice Usha Mehra, a retired judge of the Delhi High reviewed various Supreme Court judgments on reservation, reports of the.

Author: Akinotaxe Nekasa
Country: Mongolia
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Photos
Published (Last): 15 January 2011
Pages: 273
PDF File Size: 11.79 Mb
ePub File Size: 5.94 Mb
ISBN: 858-9-36464-786-4
Downloads: 54131
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Kishura

Cops didn’t delay, says victim’s friend now 23 Feb, The report of the Commission has been prepared with undue haste and with speed and submitted its report on The data collected or the sample method adopted or the repoft survey conducted by the Commission is not systematic and is incomplete, insufficient, inaccurate and the conclusions are equally prejudicial and improper.

There will be no need for any complaint if these schemes are implemented for the individual benefit and for the area developement as contemplated. The recommendation of the Commission that the State Legislature based on the recommendations of the Judicial Commission, shall indicate specifically as to what percentage of reservation benefits shall be given to which caste, races or tribes of SCs or part of or repoet within in any caste, races or tribes thereof based on their population ratio implies that the State should appoint another judicial commission to carryout the same exercise before taking any further actionmehfa on the report.

There are more than castes recognized as SCs in the Presidential List. The grouping of castes particularly with reference to Malas and Adi-andhras is incorrect. Justice Usha Mehra Commission reports that there was an unanimous resolution by the State Legislature dated, 10 th December Through out the country the scheduled castes are treated as homogenous groups as they are subjected to same social disabilities as untouchables by birth, and they were not allowed to public places and to temples.

L Lokur Committee long back recommended for report was not accepted by any Government both Central and State as there was coommission adequate representation of SCs in any sphere and there was no visible improvement in their living comjission, which is a fact even today.

There are no reservations provided for the posts of High Courts Judges and Supreme Court Judges jjustice there are also no reservations for the post of Ministers and Cabinet Comkission.


Thomas, Indrashaney are out of context and have no relevance to the issue involved and there was no issue of categorization of SCs.

Justice Usha Mehra Commission Submitted its Report to the Union Government of India

The government has created over 1, additional posts in Delhi Police and converted others into the posts of women constable on the recommendation of Justice Usha Mehra Commission’s report suggesting one third of the force should be reserved for females. Thus, the recommendation of the Commission for categorization is contradictory reort against its own findings. The Commissions report that in educational programmes and government schemes and in employment, Malas and allied communities enjoyed more benefits is also factually incorrect.

Thus, studying the status of SCs for division in Andhra Pradesh is thus violative of equality enshrined in the Constitution and discriminatory. The Commission’s observation about certain Scheduled Castes are contradictory to each other. Hence, the report of the Commission is based against the Mala and its allied castes.

Home Ministry has finally made public jutsice Justice Mehra Commission report that inquired into the lapses leading to the incident as well as ATR on its recommendations. The very appointment of Justice Usha Mehra Commission to study sub-classification issue in Andhra Pradesh alone is discriminatory and illegal.

The Commission’s report to appoint another judicial commission to be headed by a sitting or a retired High Court Judge to collect data regarding representations of various castes of the SCs in the service of the State as well as in Educational Institutions is highly impracticable and is undersirable.

Government Two government appointees in the law panel — then ex-offic The very clause suggested by the Commission for amendment is not clear. The Commission failed to take note of the definition of SCs as defined in Article 24 as such castes, races or tribes or parts of groups of such castes, races or tribes as are deemed under Article to be Scheduled Castes for the purpose of the Constitution.

The probe panel has requested the members of public to provide any information about the shocking incident gangrape of a young woman here. The report of the Commission is against the National Unity and Integrity. The Commission did not bother even to study the implications of the judgement nor discussed anywhere in the report about the findings of the Supreme Court and the remedies suggested by the Supreme Court.


CSR Compendium Touching lives of many. Hence the report is defective.


The schedule castes are not heterogeneous as commission is trying to portray. The National Commission for Scheduled Mehrra is a Constitutional authority to investigate and to inquire in to complaints with respect to the deprivation of rights and safe guards of the SCs and to submit a report which will be laid before Legislature of the State or before the Parliament as the case may be for taking appropriate action not withstanding anything contained in any other Law.

In fact the very Commission report dealt with characteristics of scheduled castes through out the country. Thus, further sub-classification, mini-classification, division or grouping is beyond the power of Parliament and thus unconstitutional. While dealing with Malas, they were also referred to Adi-andhras.

Mallu Ravi, State representative at Delhi and Shri.


Have you read iustice stories? The Commission failed to note and appreciate that if one caste is little advantaged because of their early schooling or on account of the missionaries starting schools in Coastal areas, it should not be a ground to divide the whole SCs.

Law panel’s report on death penalty reaches Home Ministry for final call 23 Sep, The Home Ministry is likely to reject Law Commission’s recommendation for abolition of death penalty, maintaining that time was not ripe yet to remove it.

The observations of the Commission that Madiga is not numerically dominant caste is also fallacious for the reasons that the Commission showed their population as Thus, the population of only Mala and Adi-andhra comes to The report of the Justice Mehra Commission is not only illegal, and unconstitutional but also opposed the judgement of the Supreme Court Constitutional bench in Dr. TomorrowMakers Let’s get smarter about money.

You won’t be able to use WhatsApp on these devices in Vodafone Business Services Digilogue – Your guide to digitally transforming your business.